Is the Ogallala aquifer really running dry? Jim Butler, senior scientist with the Kansas Geological Survey , joins Nicolas and Kent to break down the state of the High Plains aquifer, from Nebraska being in good shape to parts of Kansas where more than 60 percent of the aquifer has been depleted. He explains what it would take to slow the decline, why using water more efficiently often leads to using more of it, and how over allocated water rights make change harder.
They also cover groundwater contaminants like pesticides, what data centers could mean for water use, and a paper Jim helped write for pastors on stewardship and the science of water.
Check out this episode of the Prairie Farm Podcast to learn more!
Listen now on Podbean!
You can also find this episode on other popular podcast networks:
VIEW PODCAST TRANSCRIPT
Nicolas Lirio (0:00)
And then I'll bring us in and I'm gonna start pretty hot. I'm gonna start just with the big question that everybody's wondering about aquifer replenishment and quantities. But when you're ready, your name, your title, and this is the Prairie Farm Podcast.
Jim Butler (0:21)
Hey, I'm Jim Butler. I'm a senior scientist with the Kansas Geological Survey focused on groundwater. And this is the Prairie Farm Podcast.
Nicolas Lirio (0:33)
What? You do I mean, that was great. You do radio?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (0:33)
Beautiful. Let's listen to that panache. Yeah, that's good.
Jim Butler (0:39)
No. No. I've got a face for it though.
Nicolas Lirio (0:43)
No, hello. man. That's funny. All right. Well I'm gonna jump in. Everybody ready?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (0:43)
Ha ha ha.
Nicolas Lirio (0:51)
Awesome. Dr. Butler, not a small deal that you're joining us. You're a busy guy, so I really, really appreciate you taking the time. and I I want to start off with what everyone's thinking: the Ogalawa Aquifer renewability renewal ability. Is it there? And if it's not, at our current rate of using it, how quickly would we drain it?
Jim Butler (1:16)
Well, that kind of depend depends on where you are in the aquifer. So in Nebraska, I would say they're in pretty good shape. And I would say that they've got you know lots of time. and I mean the big concern is climate change, how that will affect rainfall, et cetera. But at this point I would say Nebraska is in good shape. Now if you go south, I mean now The High Plains aquifer covers parts of eight states in the central U.S. I mean, there's a sliver of it up in South Dakota, there's a bit in Wyoming, but then you get that Kansas, Colorado, Oklahoma, and Texas. That's kind of the main core. And you've got eastern New Mexico as well. and these areas, south of Nebraska, are facing more challenges. it's semi-arid. There's so there's not a lot of rainfall, heavily dependent on irrigation, and that's groundwater supported irrigation. And the water levels are declining. For example, in Kansas, there are areas that over 60% of the aquifer has been depleted since what we would call pre-development. This is prior to the onset of widespread pumping for irrigated agriculture. Think in Kansas, think in the 50s, 1950s. And going south, they're facing similar challenges. and Oklahoma panhandle, and then into Texas, West Texas, there's some serious challenges. So, what do we do about it? Well, you know, basically we've got to use less groundwater, and there's a variety of ways that you can do it, but the bottom line is we've just got to use less groundwater, and if we do that, if we can reduce the groundwater pumping in many of these areas. I'm not sure you can use the word sustainability, but I think you can certainly extend the lifespan of the aquifer for decades by moving forward with some actions. And I think you know the the folks I know in irrigation community here in Kansas and western Kansas in particular, they are highly adaptable
Jim Butler (3:35)
And I've resourceful individuals, otherwise they wouldn't be able to you know, make a profit out there. I've got confidence that they can rise to the challenge. It's just w we've got to get together and figure out paths forward.
Nicolas Lirio (3:51)
Is this kind of just coming to light these issues or I I feel like we've been I feel like I learned about the aquifer draining in like middle school or something and and so if if it's been happening for that long, like what is the hurdles to like solving a common sense or having a common sense solution?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (3:53)
Okay.
Jim Butler (4:10)
Well, it's difficult. I mean the yeah, let me back up and say, yeah, we've known about this for for decades. I've been at the Kansas Geological Survey, which is a research and service unit of the University of Kansas since nineteen eighty six. And I would say that entire time there's been concern about the Ogallala aquifer in western Kansas and what the future holds for it. And it's been difficult to move forward. I mean pumping reductions, if you just reduce pumping but continue with the same agricultural practices, it's gonna be a losing proposition probably in terms of the economic viability of your operation. And I think that has caused some issues. Folks hesitate to move forward with that. I think the The water rights system is a problem because we in Kansas we have water rights. And since forty-five, nineteen forty-five, you've been able to apply for a water right. A lot of those were given out in the sixties and early seventies, and we overappropriated. In other words, we gave out more water rights than the aquifer could supply. And so now we've We've got this situation. There's a seniority basis here. So the more the lig the the earlier in time irrigators will have a what is viewed as a superior water right, but it doesn't always play out that way. but there's been just hesitation to move forward, and one of the things we've done at the Kansas Geological Survey that has
Nicolas Lirio (5:53)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (6:02)
change the narrative a bit is we've developed methods such that we can tell folks in a certain geographic area if you reduce water use by a certain percent, that will cause the decline rate to reduce by a certain percent. And if you know if you want to go l larger than that, you could stabilize the water table. the water levels, but those will be that stabilization will be somewhat short term. It'll be one to maybe two and a half decades simply because of the nature of the aquifer dynamics. But there are methods that we can use. So that's helped change the narrative, but also the the agricultural community itself looking at this, some folks in Northwest Kansas said, you know, we want this resource for our kids and grandkids so they can have the same lifestyle we've had out here. And they recognize the only way they can do it is to reduce groundwater pumping. But the problem is, you know, if it's everybody kind of voluntarily re says, okay, I'll do such and such, I'll do such and such, how can you be sure that everyone's playing upon the agreed upon rules? So what has been developed is some I guess I'd call them management frameworks where a group
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (7:18)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (7:26)
of irrigators get together and say, hey, we want to reduce water use by say 20%. And you know, the majority of them in this agricultural area say, Yes, let's do it. Then everybody in that area follows suit. And this is the key is the regulatory agency comes in and makes sure that everyone's following agreed upon rules. And this was asked for by the producers themselves because if you're going to reduce your water use by 20%, you want to make sure that the guy down the road there is doing the same thing because you are changing your risk profile, obviously, by reducing water use. So we have these frameworks, this local enhanced management area framework, which is catching on and the
Nicolas Lirio (7:58)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (8:23)
The longest running one was established in two thir two thousand thirteen. The guys reduced agreed to reduce water use by twenty percent. They have achieved, based on our analysis, a twenty five percent reduction in water use, which has led to a sixty seven percent reduction in the decline rate. And here's the key. They they tell us and the ag economist at Kansas State University. tell us they're making just as much money as prior to the reductions because they're using the water more carefully. They've got soil moisture sensors, and variety of you know drones and I mean you've got all sorts of things now to help with that. But the key thing is they've been able to demonstrate they can reduce water use, but it doesn't impact the bottom line. And I'm now we're talking about net.
Nicolas Lirio (8:59)
Wow.
Jim Butler (9:23)
income, not gross but net. And so that I think that's so we've got these possibilities that and this local enhanced management area framework, this is a similar framework, the water conservation area that's a little typically smaller in it in geographic extent, but these I think have a great deal of potential if we can deploy these across western Kansas.
Nicolas Lirio (9:25)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (9:26)
Mm.
Nicolas Lirio (9:52)
Man.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (9:53)
You know, before we we get too deep into the to the weeds here, we should probably back up a little bit and talk about the significance of the Ogallala w aquifer and maybe even just like you know, I I love going out to the sand hills of Nebraska and there's a kinda I don't know if it really marks the beginning of of hitting kinda that area, but there's Ogallala, Nebraska. there's the Ogallala, Sioux, Native American well they're part of the Sioux nation or Sioux tribe, right? But that's like a specific division of that tribe. I is it is it all centered around does does all that naming for this aquifer come from Nebraska or or
Jim Butler (10:24)
Right.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (10:52)
Did no did Nebraska kind of steal the the name from the aquifer?
Jim Butler (10:58)
No, I think the I I think the name came from undoubtedly the Ogalala Sioux nation would be where the name would came from. And my that's my understanding.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (11:11)
And they were were they were they largely present in that you know, in Nebraska or or were they I guess maybe what we should back up even further and say is how big is this aquifer? Like how much area does it cover?
Jim Butler (11:27)
Well, it covers portions of eight states. And Nebraska has most of it because it's you know, you've got the sand hills there, then south of the sand hills, you've got the the aquifer east of the sand hills, so it extends a fair distance east there and as well west of and the sand hills are a great recharge area. I mean you get rain on the sands and it percolates down and helps the aquifer. So Nebraska really benefits from that.
Nicolas Lirio (11:57)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (11:57)
Does does it go into the deco does it go into the Dakotas and and obviously it's in Kansas as well. Does it make it all the way down to like Oklahoma and that? Wow. Texas and New Mexico. Wow.
Jim Butler (12:06)
Sure. Oklahoma, Texas, Eastern New Mexico. Well, eastern New Mexico. I mean, so this it's it peters out there in eastern New Mexico.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (12:14)
Wow.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (12:19)
It it seems like I heard once it's like the is it the third largest aquifer on the planet or something like that?
Jim Butler (12:26)
Yeah, it's one of the world's largest regional aquifers, providing very important agricultural production, not just for our nation, but globally as well.
Nicolas Lirio (12:36)
What what's the largest aquifer?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (12:36)
Wow.
Jim Butler (12:39)
that probably. I mean, you've got in India, the Ganges, I forget exactly what it's what it's called, but it's a huge aquifer. China, you've got the North China Plain, aquifer. And kind of depending on how you kind of c categorize some of these things. I mean, there's some large aquifers, but
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (13:00)
Is his historically where where did it I was you know, I assume
Nicolas Lirio (13:01)
Well so
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (13:06)
We we get in the habit, you know, when we look at ancient ancient land features, ancient geology, we we blame glaciers right away. is is it from the most recent ice age? Is that is that what we believe all that melt water would have would have been abs you know, you know, percolated down and and formed the Ogallala aquifer or is it more complicated than that?
Jim Butler (13:31)
Yeah, it's more complicated. And basically, yeah, the Ogallala aquifer is basically a pile of sediments. and they come from kind of erosional, they're basically erosional debris from the ancestral Rocky Mountains and similar structures to the west. So you've got the full gambit, you've got clay, silts, sands, and gravels kind of jumble together. And The water has just accumulated. I mean, we're talking millions of years here. and two to five million, I think, is kind of the standard kind of time range when various portions of the Ogalala were formed. So that water's been accumulating for a long time. The glaciers never got down to say western Kansas. Yeah. I mean you you guys in Iowa had a lot of glaciers, but
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (14:20)
really? Okay. Right, yeah.
Jim Butler (14:26)
Yeah, it just came into northeast Kansas. I'm sitting in Lawrence and the glaciers did not get to Lawrence, Kansas, but they got very close. it's it's a bit north of here.
Nicolas Lirio (14:36)
Interesting.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (14:37)
I w I would have missed that on a trivia question for sure. I would've I would have thought that that glaciers definitely would have reached the Kansas, but that's that's that's really interesting.
Nicolas Lirio (14:47)
Well, I I wanna get into something you said earlier, which goes along with like the formation of the aquifers, which is, you know, just kind of a basic science lesson for me. you said stabilization. You said the word stabilization. So two major parts of stabilization. Water coming in, water going out. how much water is actually able to permeate? I'm currently on my computer looking at a map of the Ogallala aquifer, and on Kansas it's like dark purple. There's like over a thousand feet of water is what this map says. And then, you know, it's lighter green as it goes further south. And and but but what does it actually take to recharge these? How much do they recharge every year? And then and I know in different areas they would recharge very at different rates. And how much are we currently pulling out?
Jim Butler (15:37)
Well, I mean the reason why the water levels are declining is we're pulling out considerably more than is coming in. And this method that I described that we developed at the KGS gives us a way to estimate how much water is coming in. And if you want to stabilize the water levels, you would cut your water use so the water flowing out equals the stuff coming in. Does that make sense?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (15:42)
Mm.
Nicolas Lirio (16:06)
Yeah, yeah. Totally. Well how so when water's recharging, how does that even happen? It's just rainwater being able to permeate?
Jim Butler (16:07)
And
Jim Butler (16:13)
That's right. That's right. So it's a I mean we're talking you know in Kansas, in western Kansas, the water table, this is the top of the aquifer, you know, it's gonna be hundred forty to four hundred feet below land surface. So it's I mean that percolation
Nicolas Lirio (16:16)
Interesting.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (16:36)
Wow.
Jim Butler (16:41)
process is going to take a good long time because you've got what we call a heterogeneous you've got heterogeneous material above the water table and so you could have a layer of clay so imagine you got water percolating down it hits that clay layer and it's just gonna spread out until there's a a basically a hole in that and it can continue but you've got these clays, silts
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (17:04)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (17:11)
They're distributed throughout this zone above the water table. Well, it's the same thing below the water table, but above the water table in terms of recharge. So that causes the recharge to be significantly lagged in time. But it's it comes through, but it it kind of gets all smoothed out because of that process. So you know, it could be a heavy rain one year, but that. That water is not coming down and recharging the aquifer any time soon.
Nicolas Lirio (17:44)
Percentage sorry.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (17:44)
Yeah, how so so when when when you have a heavy rain, say you get an inch an inch rain, approximately how long does it take in that that region you were just describing for for the you know that inch of rain, if I mean obviously a lot of it's gonna evaporate, so we're not even gonna absorb near all of it, but but what does get ab absorbed How long does that take to infiltrate to to just the very top of that aquifer? I mean, is it is it years, is it months, is it is it days?
Jim Butler (18:24)
It's years, it's years. And you can get fooled here. And this is something that we've recently published on or well in the final stages of publishing on. If it rains a lot, say one irrigation season you got much greater than average rainfall. So what is the response of a producer now? Is they're just not gonna pump groundwater. Because I mean if you're lifting water, you know.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (18:51)
Mm-hmm.
Nicolas Lirio (18:51)
Hm.
Jim Butler (18:54)
couple hundred feet that cost money because water's heavy so just save that don't pump it well if you're not pumping the groundwater then the water levels are oftentimes will actually go up a little bit because you're not removing much but you've got this steady recharge coming in but it may be decades old but it's coming into the system you're pumping left
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (18:57)
Right.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (19:11)
Hmm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (19:15)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (19:21)
Right, yeah.
Jim Butler (19:23)
less and so you get a rise in the water table. It's going to be short term in terms of by next year if it returns to average climatic conditions, it's you know it's going to continue to decline. But yeah, I mean the this is the key issue that we're trying to figure out and others as well is the timing of that. And as you indicated, it varies tremendously from area to area. And for example, dry stream beds are gonna be easier to infiltrate than just the yeah, you know, the rangeland or the or the farmland.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (19:52)
Mm.
Nicolas Lirio (20:04)
Hmm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (20:04)
Yeah, I never viewed it I never viewed it that way. There's essentially a line of water working its way towards the over the decades, towards collecting in the aquifer. And so there is always a level of of recharge that that is working its way there. We we tend to think of it as, that was a nice rain. That would be nice if that can get down to the aquifer someday. But that that's been going on but for for for decades of course, for centuries. And so I mean how how How old is the water, you know, a hundred feet into the aquifer? Is that are we talking that's millennium, you know, water?
Jim Butler (20:50)
Yeah, it can be. Yeah. I mean it's it's it's ancient water is for the most part. So we're mining. Well it depends on where you're getting it. I mean in in general, the water is clean. I mean it's you know, sometimes there can be some contaminants, natural contaminants, and just like everywhere, poor well construction.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (20:56)
Man, that's so interesting.
Nicolas Lirio (20:57)
Hm. How clean is that water?
Jim Butler (21:19)
and working with say like fertilizers, of ag chemicals right adjacent to a well, and then they really haven't got a good seal there at the well, then you can get movement of you can get some localized contamination as you might imagine.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (21:26)
Mm-hmm.
Nicolas Lirio (21:36)
Hm. I I I don't know if you have exact numbers on this, but like how much more currently are people pulling out of the aquifer than is recharging per year?
Jim Butler (21:49)
Well, in general, when folks ask us that question, because it's always it's asked in the context of how much do I need to reduce pumping in order to make a significant impact on these decline rates? And I would say in general we're talking between twenty five and now this would be pumping reductions. so you you would need to reduce the pumping by anywhere from twenty-five to even up to fifty percent to match the recharge. And it depends on the area. You know, some areas are are very intensely pumped, as you might imagine. and those are typically are gonna require greater reductions.
Nicolas Lirio (22:37)
So well then if you I I I I you're basically saying, Hey, on average we need to be pulling out as much water out of the ground that we're getting in rain per year on average, but wouldn't that eliminate the whole reason that they're pumping water in the first place, which is that they're not getting enough rain?
Jim Butler (22:58)
Sure. I mean the the idea here is we're s there's still gonna be irrigating. and what we are able to exploit is all the advances that that's been made in agriculture engineering, this sort of thing, so you can use less water but still be you know viable economically. but
Nicolas Lirio (23:27)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (23:28)
that requires some changes in agricultural practices. As I noted earlier, just doing the same thing that's been done for decades and reducing water use is probably not gonna be economically sound approach.
Nicolas Lirio (23:43)
What do you find? What are some of those practices? Obviously there's no one silver bullet for every farm and every farmer, but what are some of those practices that you've seen farmers implement where they can use less water and still net net a profit or maybe even more of a profit?
Jim Butler (23:59)
Well, talking to the folks out in western Kansas, one of the keys are these soil moisture sensors. So they can see what they've got in the soil column. And it may have been in the past that they would have just kept that central pivot going, but now they can see what they've got. And so they can cut it down and and cut it off and just say, I'm just gonna wait until it actually needs the water. And
Nicolas Lirio (24:11)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (24:28)
The result is that they've found that in average to wet years they've used too much water. And that's where they can make a lot of savings is use less water because now they've got a way of kind of monitoring the plants use of that water. so that's I would say that's a big deal. I think various drone applications where they're looking at the pro the electrical properties, electrical conductivity, resistivity of the of the fields, give some ideas about to where certain areas are probably not gonna be very productive regardless of what you do. So maybe don't put so much water on those. I mean, because now these center pivots you can adjust as it swings around, there can be a zone there where you put in less or more water. so there's a lot a lot more flexibility now than than they used to have. And and AI is undoubtedly gonna be very useful in this regard.
Nicolas Lirio (25:39)
Have you talked to man, Ken is it Dr. Brian Hornbuckle? Hornbuckle, is that the last name? Over at Iowa State, he developed a way to watch mo water move from satellites. So he can watch it, basically figure out how
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (25:44)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (25:58)
It was how plants are utilizing the water, right?
Nicolas Lirio (26:01)
Yeah, and and somehow they can use that to extrapolate on how much water is in the soil at at that time. And it it's very fascinating. We interviewed him a few months ago and and and I I think you're right. Like precision ag does not just mean we make sure that every soybean gets planted two inches exactly where it's supposed to go. I think that using it for water water consumption and water application is gonna be a big deal. What are these what are these water rights? What is that what does that contract look like? Is there any money paid for that at all? Or what what does that look like?
Jim Butler (26:35)
I think when you apply for a water right, I don't understand all the payments if you have to pay every annually. I I don't think it's much, but I I really can't speak to that. We have at the Kansas Geological Geological Survey, we have no right regulatory or policy making function. our mission when you cut to the chase is to provide a sound scientific foundation for decision making on natural resources issues within the state of Kansas.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (26:57)
Mm.
Jim Butler (27:04)
And so I don't get too involved in the regulatory side of things, but I can tell you you get the right to use water for beneficial for beneficial use. And now it's very difficult to get a water right in in western Kansas just because of the op over appropriation that I mentioned earlier. So you'd have to buy a water right from someone else.
Nicolas Lirio (27:32)
Wow. So these are like in inheritances. Like these are these are big deals at at this point. Th those original water rights.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (27:33)
I see.
Jim Butler (27:40)
Sure, sure. If if you've got a right and an area where the aquifer's doing reasonably well, I mean think about the difference in land prices between your land where you've got water and maybe some guy five d miles down the road where the aquifer is mainly tapped out, or he's down to like fifty gallons a minute with his wells. that's gonna be reflected in land prices.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (27:52)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (28:07)
Yeah, that's that's right. What keeps people from just illegally tapping wells all over the place? I I would think that that would be not that you know digging a well is I guess easy by any s but the the equipment's fairly simple, you know. And i mean d d d is that a problem? Do do people pop up, you know, off the record wells?
Nicolas Lirio (28:08)
Interesting.
Nicolas Lirio (28:25)
And in western Nebraska and Kansas there's like very few people out there to like
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (28:37)
Or has has that been a problem, you know, in the last fifty years and people are still utilizing those those wells that great grandpa, you know, put in a long time ago?
Jim Butler (28:48)
Well, the Division of Water Resources of the Kansas Department of Ag is monitoring water use and they do a very good job. They have regional offices, they work we also in Kansas have groundwater management districts. We have five of them. They overlie the Ogallala and other portions of the high plains, aquifer to its east. And there's a lot of tracking here. remember, we're talking about putting a well down. I mean for irrigation, it's gonna have to be a sizable diameter and it's gonna have to go down hundreds of feet. This is not a trivial actually some guy with a post hole digger big footprint, and you know, you're talking about a area where it's widely recognized that the aquifer is overappropriated and you know your neighbors
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (29:27)
Sure. It's a big it's a big foot big footprint.
Jim Butler (29:46)
are not gonna appreciate you doing that. And it's gonna be very difficult to do that. I have not heard of in the last 20 years, I have not heard of any instances of illegal wells. Now that's a problem in other nations and perhaps other areas of the US, but Kansas has a fairly robust framework for monitoring that. But just to give you an example, water use is a big deal. Like
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (29:49)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (30:15)
How much is each one of these irrigate irrigation water wells excuse me using each year? In Kansas, in the Ogallala aquifer in western Kansas, I would say virtually every well has a totalizing flow meter. And the re the amounts have to be reported annually, subject to regulatory verification. The authorities, the the Division of Water Resources personnel, they have the legal authority to go on to your land with a calibrated ultrasonic flow meter, attach it right adjacent to your meter while it's running, and you have to be within plus or minus six percent of the reading on the ultrasonic flow meter. And that's the the manufacturer spec. And if you're not, if it's off.
Nicolas Lirio (31:07)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (31:14)
And you've been you know, if you've been monkeying with things, maybe with a gearing ratio or something, the penalties are significant. And that's a request by the producers because again, we're all in this together, boys. I don't want you kind of tampering with things and using more than you are allowed to.
Nicolas Lirio (31:26)
Mm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (31:30)
Yeah. Yeah.
Jim Butler (31:39)
So if some guy is pumping the entire season while his neighbors can't do it, because they've run up against their their max amount they can use, they start wondering about how he's able to do that.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (31:50)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (31:54)
Man, imagine if if we looked at nitrate runoff like that. You know what I mean?
Nicolas Lirio (31:58)
Yeah. I think it's gonna get there. I we've been I we talked to Dr. Weber about it and he was like, Yeah, that would be very expensive. But I think it'd be cool to like make it a status for farmers where their nitrate runoff monitors it was like a s a status of pride to have that nitrate level really low, even on a big rain, but
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (32:22)
Yeah, yeah, it could get there. you know, what something w we should we should also talk about. You you mentioned contaminants, which I I assume you're meaning mostly heavy metals as far as natural contaminants go. one of the things I wonder about i in Iowa we have a lot of much all of our bedrock here is limestone and up in the northeastern part of our state we have a lot of karst topography and I I wonder you know, I've always heard that those those landscapes, their groundwater is at greatest risk for contamination. is it likely that if you're living in that area because there's been s you know, especially here in Iowa where there's been, you know what maybe century and a half, almost two centuries of of agriculture and you know probably we could say almost a century of that has been intensive agriculture. is it likely that that all that groundwater is is quite polluted now or does it still remain and paired with regulation on on you know fertilizer runoff li feedlot runoff pesticide usage
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (33:59)
Is it no, you know, that water it it definitely is gonna have some of that, but it's it's probably mostly clean, just like you'd find out in the deep parts of the Ogallala water or aquifer.
Jim Butler (34:13)
Well, you know, in karst topography you've got sinkholes and the like and you know, the runoff, the surface runoff goes into there and then it can zip around. I mean, there's nothing to kind of mediate or to moderate the the contamination r whereas in like the Ogallala, even if it's just like say fifty feet to water, you've got all this sediment that
Nicolas Lirio (34:13)
Cool.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (34:17)
Mm-hmm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (34:42)
Right.
Jim Butler (34:43)
That water has to move through and that can help reduce the severity depending on the constituents. but man, go the car's topography, it can just zip and it can it can really move out on you. And so that's you'd have to be careful there.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (34:46)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (35:01)
Yeah, so so is I mean is that like a real risk for somebody who's living in one of those areas that you know, extra water filtration or I suppose if they're getting it from some municipality that their water treatment services are having to remove more of that. Is that is that likely?
Jim Butler (35:19)
Yeah, it kinda depends on kind of the area what how the land's being used and all that jazz. But you certainly would want to be able you'd wanna treat that water. You would not just wanna say, Okay, I've got this this well, let's tap it into karst groundwater. I I think you'd you'd certainly wanna treat it to make sure your family's safe.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (35:35)
Yeah, it's groundwater, so it must be okay, yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (35:44)
d does it almost become a I know this is getting away from groundwater a little bit, but in in an area like that, is it almost because you can have a more known variable I guess, does it almost become just more efficient to just take it from surface water, you know, tap into the Mississippi River and then treat what's in that water and and turn that into drinking water. or or is is it always no mat you know b aside from like some really huge pollution issue, is it always better to to get groundwater when you can get groundwater?
Jim Butler (36:28)
Well, I would say like the Mississippi, if you can if you have a a network of wells f fairly close to the river, that's what you'd wanna you'd want to pump those for the 'cause they'd be drawing in water from the Mississippi, but then again, you've got that path through the sediments and so that's gonna clean up the water a bit. So y you may not have to treat it as aggressively as you would if you just remove it directly from the Mississippi. I mean
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (36:38)
okay.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (36:46)
Mm-hmm.
Jim Butler (36:56)
That's certainly with the Kansas River, which is here in Lawrence, there are wells that they are pumping like that that I think helps moderate the the contaminant threat.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (37:11)
Sure. And when when when a you know a pesticide like let's say atrazine or something, so something that's known to make its way into groundwater, when that gets there, I mean is it does it degrade you know the the old phrase dilution is the solution to pollution, but d To me it just seems like that water's so ancient, it takes so long for something to get there that once it's there, you're not getting it out. You gotta filter it out when you're when you pump it out. I mean, is that is is for for you know people hydrologists who who are really focused on groundwater resources, is that like not just what Nicholas has been talking about with, you know, overconsumption and and destabilization of the resource, but is are these man-made compounds that are making their way into the groundwater, is that just going to be a building problem throughout time, throughout, you know, civilization going civilization going forward?
Jim Butler (38:20)
Well, I think it depends on the constituent and how yeah, it can be degraded as it moves through the material. but some of these things are gonna be fairly conservative con s chemically, so meaning they don't degrade much. And so certainly that's that's gonna be an issue if there's a fair amount of it moving downward. and it will just continue to be a threat. I think. you know, th in some areas of western Kansas, it may be that we've got stuff coming down, but just as we spoke about it earlier, there just hasn't been enough time for it to reach the water table. So I think you have to be ever vigilant about it.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (39:05)
That's ki that's kinda scary. I mean, 'cause there's been not I mean, fifty years ago, if there's water that still hasn't reached, you know, the main parts of the aquifer that was u you know, a herbicide that was used before we really understood how dangerous it it could be. I mean, that might not have even made it there yet, right?
Jim Butler (39:26)
depends on the area, but cer certainly in the deeper portions. I mean it's it's again it varies tremendously in space and in terms of the timing of that. But yeah I don't think we've had many problems on that side yet in in certainly in western Kansas. I think in other areas although I you know the United States Geological Survey, which is different from the Kansas, I mean there's a federal survey and then there's the state surveys
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (39:29)
Mm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (39:35)
Sure.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (39:52)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (39:55)
they've done a lot of work on atrazine and other of these ag chemicals and I'd have to defer to their to their assessment of that because I just don't know enough about it to to really say anything of importance.
Nicolas Lirio (40:13)
Yeah. Yeah. And it's it's you know, it's a it's a important but complicated topic for sure, just because chemistry killed a lot of people's dreams of being doctors. So but Yeah Yeah, that's true, that's true. my gosh. I wanna move on to a little bit the reason where I was when I was like, This is the guy, is this paper that
Jim Butler (40:24)
That was organic chemistry, I think. Yes.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (40:27)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Nicolas Lirio (40:38)
you sent me, I asked you, like, hey, is there anything that we should know? And you sent me this paper, and I was like, man. This is for a journal of Bible and theology, but this is the title Groundwater Depletion A Global Challenge for Intergenerational Equity. and your very first sentence the continuing depletion of the world's aquifers has given rise to a profound intergenerational equity.
Jim Butler (41:06)
inequity.
Nicolas Lirio (41:07)
Inequities, thank you. Yeah. It
Nicolas Lirio (41:12)
Usually like people aren't like when we talk to scientists, they have like thoughts, you know, how the data may drive culture. But you wrote a paper on it. You and it was someone else, Bear Johnson, wrote a paper on it. And then in the second paragraph, you have Psalms twenty-four, one through two. So it was like, okay, this this gentleman is very clearly
Jim Butler (41:27)
Terry Johnson.
Nicolas Lirio (41:39)
Like they're thinking about culture, they're thinking about how we interact with the earth, they're thinking about how we interact with our neighbors. That was a word used quite a bit in the paper. And I I I'm curious what motivated you to draw to like write something like this because it felt very related to the podcast we do as a whole.
Jim Butler (41:57)
Well, there's a story behind this, and that is my college roommate, Got was went into he was majoring in government with a minor in religion. He ended up following the religion path, and he became the what would be the the director of a theological seminary in Richmond, Virginia that has published this journal, Interpretation, since nineteen forty seven. And they decided to do a special issue on water. So he contacts me and I'd kept in contact with him over the years, and he said, We really need you to write something kind of more from the scientific perspective and on groundwater that would appeal to our readership. And this is mainly for pastors. I think it's Methodists, if I'm or Presbyterian. Now this is I don't know. I forgot now. so don't quote me on that. but
Nicolas Lirio (43:00)
Ha ha.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (43:01)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (43:05)
So I agreed to it, and I have a friend here at KU who is just retired. Well, he retired a few years ago from the chemistry department. And in addition to his standard chemistry work, he had worked at the intersection of Christianity and science. So I recruited him to join me on this paper so that we could speak to the this audience of
Nicolas Lirio (43:29)
Hm.
Jim Butler (43:34)
pastors beyond just the standard scientific terminology. So we tried to mesh it there. But yeah, I felt my roommate former roommate asked me, I felt like I should rise to the occasion and put that together. That took us some time, I have to say.
Nicolas Lirio (43:51)
I I it is very interesting. I w I wanna f yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (43:52)
bet, yeah. Yeah. I think that's ki I think that's so when was that paper written? Do you have the date on it there, Nicholas?
Jim Butler (44:00)
I think it was twenty four is when it came out.
Nicolas Lirio (44:02)
Mm-hmm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (44:03)
Twenty twenty four. Yeah, so it seems like that that kind of has been following a trend here recently where I mean for a long time science and Christianity were were kind of at odds with each other. And and I would say even more so environmental science and and Christianity were at odds with each other and it seems i it and I mean to credit credit to people such as yourself who are saying no actually the opposite should be true. If you believe that God made this place, then you should also believe that it's important that you take care of it. And if you believe that God made the people that live here and that He's also going to make the people that are going to live here after we live here, then you should probably care that you take care of it for them as well. But I don't know, is that something you've seen from from the, you know, academic end of of all of this? Are are you sensing that that change as well?
Jim Butler (45:15)
can't say that I am. I I mean Carrie Carrie my my co author has worked a lot with this philosophy that the that science and Christianity are natural to mesh well together and we tried to bring that out in that paper and that was you know that's I mean he
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (45:20)
Well now I'm discouraged again. Okay.
Nicolas Lirio (45:21)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (45:45)
He was very well versed in all the literature and so that was very helpful in in kind of constructing our discussion in that area. But I I can't say that that I sense there's a a big change. I have tried to get that paper out there for for people to read because we try to make it a something that a general reader could could follow and kind of make kind of lay out the issues that we are facing here in Kansas and that are you know that others are facing across the world in terms of dealing with these aquifers that are so critical for supporting irrigated agriculture.
Nicolas Lirio (46:39)
Hm. Well, in it you outline three fixes and but you argue that only one is viable and we went over that a little bit with like, hey, we gotta cut how much we're pumping by somewhere between twenty five and fifty percent, which means we'll have to change our agricultural practices. But then you argue that the other two aren't aren't viable at all. could you go over those on on I guess they're proposed by other people and and you're just almost giving commentary on them.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (46:39)
Yeah, yeah.
Jim Butler (47:06)
Yeah, I the so what do you do? You gotta reduce groundwater. So one way of doing it is to replace the groundwater with surface water. And the issue we face in western Kansas, well I mean that this is not Iowa, this is western Kansas where it rains a lot less. There is no excess surface water to be had. And what happens
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (47:32)
Mm.
Nicolas Lirio (47:33)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (47:36)
And I think I brought it out in that paper, is originally the rivers out there and streams, they're groundwater fed. The water table was above the level of water in the stream. So water flowed from the aquifer into the stream. But with intensive pumping, you've drawn down the aquifer so significantly that you reverse that crate that gradient and water is flowing from the stream into the aquifer. Result is dry stream beds. and so there's very, very little surface water out there in western Kansas. So then you're talking about exporting it in some big massive project that's gonna cost billions of dollars. You have to lift the water, you know, a significant distance, and again the water's heavy, you're gonna need a lot of it to to grow row crops. I mean they can do that.
Nicolas Lirio (48:15)
Wow.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (48:34)
Okay.
Nicolas Lirio (48:34)
Just from the Missouri or where would they get it?
Jim Butler (48:37)
That's the proposals. They take it the far northeastern can corner of Kansas, take it out of the Missouri, ship it west. I mean, there's so many issues here with imminent domain, you name it. Of course, all the downstream states are not gonna go for this because of the impact, the potential impact on barge traffic, etc. and so it's all sorts of things. it's it's not gonna fly.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (48:49)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (48:57)
Yeah. Yeah. All sorts of things, man.
Jim Butler (49:06)
but it keeps get banding about and some people are saying, let's take it from Canada. I don't think the Canadians are gonna go for it, but you know, who knows? but that's just not for us, for agriculture, it's not gonna work. If you say, Hey, I want to take water out of the Mississippi River basin, whether it's out of the Missouri or wherever, and send it to the front range. So that reduces their water use of the Colorado basin, which we all know, Colorado Colorado River Basin, which is you got serious issues. So there could be some mega deal, and then Kansas could siphon off. You could okay, like five or ten percent of that
Nicolas Lirio (49:42)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (49:42)
Mm-hmm.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (49:50)
So wait, wait, do I understand this right? They're wanting to pipe water from the Mississippi all the way to the Colorado, but because that'll run across Kansas, Kansas could pop a hole in the the pipe and
Nicolas Lirio (50:02)
Ha ha ha.
Jim Butler (50:02)
Well, I mean this would all this would all be an an agreement, a formal agreement. I was using that a little casually. I mean if something like that happened, well, the front range with all those people, they could they can probably pay a a you know, a significant portion of it and still be viable and of course the federal government would come in with a lot. but you know, you can't
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (50:07)
my goodness. Yeah, yeah.
Jim Butler (50:31)
You can't build something like that just for agriculture out in western Kansas. There's there's you know, it would take massive, massive subsidies and it's not gonna
Nicolas Lirio (50:40)
It's it interesting that basically every scientist we talk to has to also have a minor in economics. Otherwise no one will listen to him. Not not like to discredit what your work is, but it's like until you start talking to about people's pocketbooks, it's like, you know, it's hard to even get anyone's attention.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (50:52)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (50:58)
Well you know, the Chinese have done this. They have taken water out of the Yangtze and sent it sent it to Beijing and Tianjin, which are the two major cities there in northern portions of China. They have populations of like I think total population is something like thirty seven million people. well I mean, so you could see they send it up there and that water replaces groundwater. And so that's been helpful.
Nicolas Lirio (51:25)
Hmm.
Jim Butler (51:27)
for the aquifer up there. And then they've able to take some of the water, their excess water that's being shipped up and put it into basically like dry stream beds to recharge the aquifer. But that's a huge, huge project.
Nicolas Lirio (51:40)
Interesting. Yeah, and you need millions and millions of people to benefit from it to be able to pay for it.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (51:42)
Yeah, and I just I just don't see
Jim Butler (51:47)
That's exactly right.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (51:47)
Well and and unless you're draining unless you're draining back into the same watershed, I just don't see how it's not a big loss for the people downstream of where it's being diverted from.
Jim Butler (51:59)
Well, that's a very wet area. So yeah, for in that case in the China Ch yeah. It it's the difference is not gonna be a major factor.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (52:04)
Okay, so it it makes no it makes no difference.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (52:10)
I is that in this case and I and I agree with you, I I don't think it's super likely we would do this, but would is that the understanding for the people in the the you know, living closer to the Mississippi River that yeah, we're taking a bunch of water, but you guys have so much water you're not even gonna notice. and does the Colorado I can't remember, does it does it enter back into the Does it flow to the Arkansas and that dumps back into the Mississippi? It it goes it goes yeah, it's in a different drainage basin, right? Different watershed.
Jim Butler (52:39)
No. No.
Nicolas Lirio (52:40)
No, it goes to like the Grand Canyon.
Jim Butler (52:43)
Yeah, I mean what happens is yeah, there's there water is being transferred from the Colorado River basin over across the continental divide to be used in areas in the front range. and and they're also pumping significant quantities of water too out of the aquifers they have and the water level can be two thousand feet down and they're they're pumping it and that's obviously very expensive.
Nicolas Lirio (52:58)
Hmm.
Nicolas Lirio (53:11)
Well then the other f sorry.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (53:12)
This this might well th while we're on it, it it kind of feels like a dumb question, but where does this water go? So i it's the the I understand the problem that the recharge rate for an aquifer is just so much slower than the take rate is. but matter is not created or destroyed. So it it still exists within the the system of our planet. Is it is it most of it when it goes out and waters crops, obviously a lot of it ends up in, you know, we'll just say the biosphere and plants and animals. considering humans animals along with that when we eat those those products. But is is it just is the fear that it's well, when we get it out of the aquifer, some of it drains surface water, ends up in the ocean, most of it just gets ev evaporated. I mean, where so so I guess are we are we literally just squeezing the sponge until there's no w you know left un unregulated, uns unhindered, un unslowed, whatever you wanna say, given enough time. Do we just squeeze all the water out of the sponge, which is the western you know, part of our country. If if we were to drain the Colorado River and we were to suck up the you know the the more vulnerable parts of the Og Ogallala aquifer and that water just exists in the ocean, it exists in in the atmosphere. I mean where where's it going that once it's pumped and or and once the surface water is is is siphoned away?
Jim Butler (54:57)
Well, I mean a lot as you indicated is evaporated off, vapot transpired, and then it's just it it's just gonna move east or southeast depending on the direction of the it's going to Iowa, man. We need to shift course. Get it down. Yeah that
Nicolas Lirio (55:09)
Hm. It's going to Iowa. That's where it's going.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (55:13)
Wow. Okay.
Nicolas Lirio (55:16)
Yeah, yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (55:18)
Ca c well, 'cause I don't I don't see that like the I don't see a fear of well we're gonna have I mean, I know part of climate change is from our melting ice caps, we have rising sea levels. But I don't ever see that that mentioned for, you know, we've exported all of our water from the ground, it all ended up in the ocean, a lot of it's evaporating, but our ocean levels go up. That's that that's not part of it, is it?
Jim Butler (55:40)
Yeah, the ocean levels there's been studies showing that the ocean levels have risen as a result of significant groundwater pumping. And then that if you get Yeah, that's I haven't been involved I haven't been involved in those, but yes, that's certainly
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (55:50)
Really? Okay, that's news to me. That's
Nicolas Lirio (55:53)
No like measurable amount.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (56:00)
I mean it makes sense mechanically, you know, you're taking a block from one area and you're putting that block somewhere else and
Nicolas Lirio (56:06)
Well yeah, but measurable? Like enough that crazy.
Jim Butler (56:08)
Yes, apparently it's measurable. I can't quote v there have been studies on that recently. I know there's one by a retired USGS scientist, Konaka Linny Kanikau. I just can't remember the details.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (56:28)
it's interesting. This week, I don't know if you ever tune into the Meteor Podcast, Dr. Butler. It's it's an they have, you know, interesting topics all the time. And and this week they interviewed a hydrologist. And I believe she mentioned that ten percent of the American population survives off of that Colorado River watershed. And yeah. And and
Nicolas Lirio (56:52)
Ten percent of the US? Okay, yeah, yeah. Okay.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (56:59)
That's all I can see when I picture this is there's there's going to have to be a displacement of people because eventually a place becomes like Death Valley where it's uninhabitable. You know, y y it's a it's it's an inhospitable place to try and and make a go. is that where this leads with with you know, draining these water these freshwater resources? Is I mean do you do you project that unless we have some significant change that that's probably going to result.
Jim Butler (57:34)
Well, I know you read reports on like Phoenix and Tucson are gonna be in a world of hurt if some of these proposed reductions or this last range round excuse me, of proposed reductions go into effect. I think they'll do a deal. one of the issues, however, is you know, if you wanna live in a desert, you just you know.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (58:00)
Yeah. Gotta solve the water problem.
Jim Butler (58:03)
you gotta be careful there. And and you'll see that in looking in Phoenix. There there's some areas that are no longer able to pump groundwater and I guess they're they're trucking it in, which doesn't sound like a good a long term solution to me. I mean you've got like Los Angeles, San Diego, I mean they're right next to the Pacific. They can do a lot of with DSAL and so I I would think
Nicolas Lirio (58:21)
Interesting.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (58:29)
Mm-hmm.
Jim Butler (58:32)
But of course they also, I mean LA, they've had some, you know, really good water engineers and lawyers. So they're in pretty good shape when you talk about these interstate compacts and the like. Arizona may be in a less preferred position in that respect.
Nicolas Lirio (58:53)
Well, you know what's kinda interesting is the percentage of the produce you get at the grocery store that comes from outside of Phoenix is is not insignificant. So if they can't get water anymore and I'm we're not I'm not trying to paint a a doom or picture, but it might be in a few years you know, and Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (58:54)
Yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (58:59)
Yeah, yeah.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (59:09)
Well it just matters. This matters is what is what we're getting at.
Jim Butler (59:13)
Well, I think that's why they you know, there was such an outcry about the Saudi pumping for Alfalfa and then shipping it to Saudi Arabia for feed. you know, that's that's really not the way you want to run things.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (59:29)
Hm. Yeah.
Nicolas Lirio (59:29)
Yeah. Did so I wanna go on to the third way, but before we do that, a question that I've been thinking is like, is there a way to terraform the ground level that water can permeate faster where you can take advantage of a higher percentage of the rain that does fall in western Kansas and Nebraska?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (59:39)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (59:57)
Yeah, I'm not as familiar with that. I mean, the sand hills maintaining areas like the sand hills in Nebraska, which would be which would allow a lot of recharge. and south of Garden City in Kansas, we've got sand hills, but they've got center pivots all over the doggone place. And that's you know, that's a decision that was made. perhaps the maybe some of those could have been reserved for recharge areas to get that that as you describe. and maybe in the future some of these areas get tapped out. there'll be more of that. But as you know, yeah, the I I I just
Nicolas Lirio (1:00:35)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (1:00:49)
Don't know enough about that to to say what sort of mechanisms could be used to alter the natural surface so that you get enhanced recharge. But if yeah, the only thing it would do is it would be the the rainfall because again, there's no additional water to be had. I mean there is treatment of wastewater in some of the cities out there, and then they they recharge the aquifer with treated wastewater.
Nicolas Lirio (1:00:56)
Yeah.
Nicolas Lirio (1:01:02)
Yeah. sorry.
Nicolas Lirio (1:01:18)
Like a reverse well. interesting. so then the third one is efficiency subsidies. But the difference between what you are saying and the importing water from the Missouri River aqueduct, is that they've actually tried this one, right? Efficiency subsidies. What I don't understand what that is.
Jim Butler (1:01:22)
Exactly.
Jim Butler (1:01:40)
yeah, yeah. Natural race Natural resource economists have known since like I don't know eighteen seventy or so that developing methods to more efficiently utilize a natural resource does not lead to less use of that resource. It typically would lead to more. And this is this Jevons paradox. I think we mentioned that in the paper. He was a natural resource economist in the UK who did this with respect to coal. but yeah, we've you know, in in Kansas, for example, we've done an analyses of across the period when they went from central pivots where they're just spraying the water up, you know, with their sprinklers, down to where these you know, these low nozzles that they have now. And it's yeah, we can't see any improvements in terms of the of water use because I think i you take those approaches, then you've got more water to use and the economically sound approach, certainly over the short term, would say, Hey, I'm going to irrigate more land or I'm going to grow a more thirsty crop because now I've got more water to be used. and so what I tried to say in that paper is the way to do it is say, hey, if you have got a binding agreement, some sort of legally binding agreement to reduce water use by a certain percent, then those subsidies make sense because then you will actually reduce the the water use.
Jim Butler (1:03:41)
and that would be the tool to help you get to to reduce water use by twenty whatever percent. But no, go on.
Nicolas Lirio (1:03:43)
Hmm.
Nicolas Lirio (1:03:48)
What so sorry. If you by you and your your peers metrics were able to snap your finger and get water use to a level down twenty five to fifty percent to a level where you consider it stable. and does the does do Kansas and Nebraska support the population that it currently supports, not just with water intake, but obviously economically. and the way that you've the the states have built their economics, it won't come crumbling down. Like is is there a s civilization stability that is possible if you actually drop the water qual the water use down to the level that makes sense mathematically?
Jim Butler (1:04:42)
think you know, I don't know about all the different areas. I mean there are some areas in west central Kansas where they've already transitioned from irrigated agriculture to dry land simply because they had less aquifer to begin with there. but I think certainly we can reduce water use to to significantly extend the the lifespan of the aquifer without having a economic crisis. But you know, how much I don't know enough about the of ag e economics and agri agriculture engineering to to say kind of where that limit gets reached where it's th there's nothing much you can do. it's gonna be an impact. I mean you can imagine shifting, say from corn to say winter wheat and and some crops like that. of course there's you know the economics come into play there with the pricing and all that jazz. So I can't really comment.
Nicolas Lirio (1:05:50)
Yeah.
Nicolas Lirio (1:05:53)
Well, we're finding in Iowa, there you know, there's issue with how much corn and bean we're doing. But one of the problems on a per farmer basis is humans like to use all the resources at their disposal. And a lot of people have levered themselves to for agriculture that is corn and beans, you know, that takes the most off of their land per doll in dollars per acre as they possibly can. And so even if they did switch, they're They're levered. And they're levered for twenty or thirty or forty years. So, that it become it becomes a difficult topic, that we've been Kent and I have just been following the threads and they're all intertwined and it's a very difficult topic. Well, I wanna move to the last one that I asked timidly before beforehand if you would even be willing to address it. And you said that there were a couple things that you knew about but weren't an expert in all of it. Our good friend and our listener kill or listenership killer data centers. in Iowa, in from 2015 to 2025, we've gone from seven data centers to 17 data centers. and there are a lot of requested in 10 years, 2015 to 2025. Yep, we've we've added right about 10 data centers. And I'm curious, are in Kansas, are people
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:07:07)
What was that time what was that timeline? Twenty five till this sh until okay. Fifteen to twenty five. Okay.
Nicolas Lirio (1:07:19)
Are data centers being proposed? What are people's thoughts that you've noticed? But most importantly, would they touch the aquifers? Like what what's the water proposition in these places where you guys already are having water issues?
Jim Butler (1:07:34)
Yeah, I mean, it is obviously it's a hot topic everywhere in the United States, probably right now. And there's pushes to put data centers virtually everywhere in Kansas. And yeah, so the it really comes down to I mean the water's being used for cooling for the most part. And how is that done? So you could see if there's some sort of recycled system where it would lead to perhaps less water. I mean they're gonna have to buy water rights to to get that. And so the water right will change from an ag based one to an industrial based one. And there's a diminishment of the of the volume, allowed volume when you do that. Because I mean with ag you're going to get some a potential irrigation return flow. Water trick trickles down to the aquifer. That is industrial applications, not necessarily
Nicolas Lirio (1:08:21)
Mm.
Jim Butler (1:08:33)
So there is I guess a little bit of a haircut you take when you do that. so they're gonna have to have a water right and you know it it depends on you know how they're they're structuring it. Are they gonna have recycling system or is it just all gonna be consumed? and I think that's a big issue that will help kind of, you know, how they how the devil's in the detail here. And I mentioned it earlier too and prior to the start of this, that I'm a little concerned about all the electronic waste that are generated by these data centers because you know you got at the big data centers, you got thousands of servers, and just statistics tell you that you're gonna have just a certain percentage of those going down all the time. And if you got thousands of them, you're you're going to start getting a fair volume of this electronic waste. how do you handle that and the potential for groundwater contamination if it's not handled well? But this is an area that is is very high profile across the state, whether it's in the Ogallala area or here in eastern Kansas, where we're getting, I don't know, 38, 40 inches of rainfall each year.
Nicolas Lirio (1:09:39)
Hm.
Nicolas Lirio (1:09:46)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (1:09:56)
it's it's still a big issue. and everybody's gotta have a water right to to use it.
Nicolas Lirio (1:09:59)
Does
Nicolas Lirio (1:10:02)
Ha have you ever laid eyes on what AI data centers are proposing their water use would be or where they would get it from or like would they put it back into the ground after pulling it up? 'Cause it's not like they dump it out ever I i I think it literally just goes through tubes and the cool water cools the machines. I'm pretty sure that's how it's used. And then like if it stays in the tubes, they could just send it back down the ground, but I'm very ignorant on this topic. So I don't know you've ever
Jim Butler (1:10:31)
Yeah, I'm I'm pretty ignorant as well. I do know there's one proposal out in western Kansas where they're proposing to buy thirty six water rights that are center pivots and then convert that to use in a data center, but I don't know how they're handling the the cooling there.
Nicolas Lirio (1:10:53)
Interesting. Well, yeah, the the data center, I mean, everybody's keeping a close eye on it and I I don't know. But you bring up an interesting topic. How do landfills interact with like you know, water coming down? I mean, landfills here in Iowa, we got a six hundred acre landfill. I imagine if we had giant aquifers that it would permeate that and start to so what does that look like?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:11:06)
yeah.
Jim Butler (1:11:17)
Well sure landfills are could be a source of contamination. Obviously in Iowa, they've got certain rules about testing the material around the landfills. I did a project, I don't know, maybe twenty some years ago in close to the the Mississippi there in Iowa where we're looking at various Test, well tests, tests where you perturb the water level in the well and you and you watch it come back to the original position, and from that you get some idea of the permeability. And this is the property that would control how rapidly material would move in a subsurface in the absence of chemical reactions. so I know Iowa really keeps track of of their landfills because of the potential contaminant source they could become. And I don't know how they're handling these electronic wastes. Are they gonna I mean potent potentially they could be using them to extract various strategic minerals and stuff like this. imagine someone could go in and and maybe make a profitable business out of that, but then still there's gonna be a lot of other stuff that they're gonna throw away.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:12:23)
Mm.
Nicolas Lirio (1:12:41)
Yeah. I mean th yeah, there's a lot that I actually looked into this the other day because I was curious, like GPUs and CPUs specifically. The silicone is useless. The like the the mi the chips, the like transistors sitting in the chip, those are useless. But they do strip basically all the metal. But that does that leaves a plastic casing and many silicone chips, you know, that are that I don't know where they end up. You know, I'm sure some sort of contract with a giant landfill and but so with Kansas, you guys don't have 'cause I would imagine it'd be just as important to you guys if you're like our drinking water comes from this, you know, comes from these aquifers and we don't want it going through the landfills, you know, and and Kent's s four children's dirty diapers hanging out, you know, all over the you know, and much more poisonous things that might be in the landfill. Look, everyone's got dirty diapers. We don't need to measure the contents, all right.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:13:29)
Hey, better than your dirty diapers.
Jim Butler (1:13:38)
No, I mean Kansas has the same issues. I mean the challenge always is when you're siting these facilities to be very careful about where you're siting them so as to minimize the possibility of of the water moving down into and threatening nearby water drinking water supplies.
Nicolas Lirio (1:14:02)
Hm. Man. Well, Doctor Butler, we really, really appreciate you hanging out with us. Thank you so much.
Jim Butler (1:14:10)
Right, it's very interesting. I appreciate your questions and the discussion.
Nicolas Lirio (1:14:14)
Yeah. If people want to learn more about aquifers and the studies you've been doing and your colleagues have been doing, where would they go?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:14:15)
Yeah, definitely.
Jim Butler (1:14:21)
Well then you go to the Kansas Geological Survey website. We have publications there. And we've got, where is this? We've got, I think I sent you one of these. There's a public information circular that you can get. You can download it from our website. That'll give you information about the about the aquifer. And on my website, I have a web page. Let me rephrase it. This paper that you mentioned earlier is let me put it up here. you can download it there as well. And so you can go into personnel at the Kansas Geological website and you'll see my name. You click on, I think there's like more info or Vita or something like that, and then there'll be a list of recent publications and virtually all of them you can click on and download. And so if people are interested, that would be one thing to do. and but look at the public information circulars that we have as well, because they cover a variety of topics.
Nicolas Lirio (1:15:31)
Yeah, absolutely. Well
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:15:32)
Cool. Nick you gotta ask your your your your your question.
Nicolas Lirio (1:15:35)
All right, all right. We've been getting enough complaints. I haven't been doing it. So before we go, if you could change one thing about the world with a snap of a finger, what would you change?
Jim Butler (1:15:46)
What would I change with a snap of the finger?
Jim Butler (1:15:52)
That that's a very good question. I think it w I would like us all to be able to live together and in peaceful a peaceful coexistence. How about that?
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:16:05)
Yeah. Yeah, love it. That's
Nicolas Lirio (1:16:05)
That's a good one. World peace. you'd be surprised. You're I think you're the first person out of like a hundred people that we've asked that that has said world peace. man. Well
Jim Butler (1:16:16)
That may be a little overly optimistic, but still we can have we can aspire to that.
Nicolas Lirio (1:16:23)
Well, you gotta have front runners and the optimism, you know, you gotta you gotta have But well, thank you so much. And for everyone listening, Dr. Butler has a ginormous mind and has done some incredible work, but just like you know, we say every week, conservation happens just one mind at a time.
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:16:23)
Yeah.
Jim Butler (1:16:43)
Thanks a lot, guys. I've enjoyed it.
Nicolas Lirio (1:16:43)
Man. Yeah. don't get off yet. Just give it like
Kent Boucher- Hoksey Seeds (1:16:44)
Yep. Thank you. This was great.
Jim Butler (1:16:48)
Okay.
