Why Black Hawk Might Be the Midwest's Most Misunderstood Historical Figure
You see his name everywhere in the Midwest. Black Hawk County in Iowa. Black Hawk College in the Quad Cities. Black Hawk State Bank. Chicago Blackhawks. Heck, there are even Blackhawk helicopters flying around the world. The guy's name has global recognition. But here's the thing—most people who see his name on a school or a county probably don't know the real story of who Black Hawk was or what he actually wanted.
According to Dr. Patrick J. Jung, a professor of history and cultural anthropology at the Milwaukee School of Engineering and author of The Black Hawk War of 1832, the historical figure we remember is often drastically different from the man himself. "People always want to paint him as this bloodthirsty savage warrior," Jung explains in a recent conversation on the Prairie Farm Podcast, "but that's not who he was at all."
Black Hawk—whose name in the Sauk language was Makatamishikiakyak, meaning "black sparrowhawk"—was a member of the Sauk tribe, not the leader of some mysterious "Black Hawk Indians" as many assume. He lived in what's now the Quad City area along the Mississippi River, in a village called Saukenuk near present-day Rock Island, Illinois. And what he wanted more than anything wasn't warfare or glory—it was to farm his land and live in peace.
The Farmer Who Didn't Want War
One of the biggest misconceptions about Black Hawk centers on the conflict that made him famous: the Black Hawk War of 1832. Popular history often portrays this as Black Hawk leading a violent uprising against American settlers. Jung's research tells a completely different story.
"Despite the opinions of several federal officials in the region, Black Hawk did not intend to make war when he crossed the Mississippi; in fact, he hoped to avoid it," Jung writes in The Black Hawk War of 1832, published by the University of Oklahoma Press. The war, which lasted only from May to August of 1832, resulted from "a series of misinterpretations" rather than Black Hawk's aggressive intentions.
What Black Hawk actually wanted was to return to his village and plant corn. In his autobiography, Life of Ma-ka-tai-me-she-kia-kiak, published in 1833, Black Hawk makes his motivations clear. He wasn't trying to start a war—he was trying to go home. The 1804 Treaty of St. Louis, in which a group of Sauk representatives ceded tribal lands east of the Mississippi while allegedly drunk, had forced his people from their homeland. Black Hawk never accepted this treaty as legitimate, and understandably so.
"He just wanted to grow his corn," Jung notes. "He was a warrior, yes, but he spent most of his life farming. That was his identity. That was what he loved." The man who wanted nothing more than to tend his fields along the Rock River has been remembered primarily as a warlike figure—a fundamental misunderstanding of who he was.
The Loyalty Question
Another aspect of Black Hawk's story that's often misunderstood is his alliance with the British during the War of 1812. Many Americans viewed this as treasonous betrayal. But from Black Hawk's perspective, the British had been better trading partners and allies to the Sauk people than the Americans, who were aggressively pushing them off their land.
"The British didn't want their land," Jung points out. "The British wanted to trade with them. The Americans wanted them gone." This wasn't about Black Hawk being anti-American out of some inherent hatred—it was about survival and maintaining a way of life. When you're watching your homeland systematically taken from you, you ally with whoever might help you keep it.
A Legacy Built on Misunderstanding
The aftermath of the 1832 war was devastating. While white casualties numbered around 77, the Sauk people lost between 450 to 600 members, according to Jung's research. The conflict wasn't really a war—it was closer to a massacre. Black Hawk and his followers, known as the British Band, were outmatched, outnumbered, and ultimately destroyed not just by American forces but by the complex web of intertribal rivalries that isolated them from potential Native allies.
Yet Black Hawk's fame never faded. Part of this stems from his autobiography, which Jung notes is "considered the first real work in American literature of American Indian autobiography." Published just a year after the war ended, the book became an immediate bestseller and remains in print today. Through interpreter Antoine LeClaire, Black Hawk told his story, and historians largely agree that when corroborated with other sources, his account is remarkably accurate.
But even the existence of his autobiography feeds into the misunderstanding. Black Hawk became famous enough to have his story published, famous enough to have counties and schools and sports teams named after him—but often for the wrong reasons. He's remembered as a fierce warrior when he wanted to be remembered as a farmer. He's seen as starting a war when he was desperately trying to avoid one.
Why This Matters Now
The story of Black Hawk hits close to home for anyone who's spent time in the Quad Cities or driven through Black Hawk County. These places, these names—they're everywhere. And they represent something important: a connection to the land and its history that goes deeper than we often realize.
The prairies and riverlands that Black Hawk fought so hard to preserve are the same landscapes many of us are working to restore today. When someone plants a native prairie, when they choose Big Bluestem or Indian Grass over a sterile lawn, they're reconnecting with an ecosystem that people like Black Hawk understood and valued long before conservation became a buzzword. The Sauk people didn't need studies to tell them that native ecosystems were worth protecting—they lived in harmony with them for generations.
Black Hawk's story reminds us that history is rarely as simple as we make it out to be. The man behind the name wasn't a savage or a hero in the Hollywood sense—he was a complex human being trying to protect his home, his people, and his way of life against impossible odds. And if we're going to put his name on everything from helicopters to high schools, we owe it to him to get the story right.
For more on Black Hawk and the history of the Upper Midwest, check out Dr. Patrick J. Jung's The Black Hawk War of 1832, available through the University of Oklahoma Press and on Amazon. Black Hawk's own autobiography is freely available through Project Gutenberg and various other sources online—well worth an afternoon's read.
If you're looking to restore a piece of prairie in Iowa or the greater Midwest, consider native seed mixes from Hoksey Native Seeds that help bring back the landscapes Black Hawk knew and loved. Because conservation, like history, happens one mind at a time.
---
Sources:
- Jung, Patrick J. The Black Hawk War of 1832. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2007. https://www.oupress.com/9780806139944/the-black-hawk-war-of-1832/
- Black Hawk. Life of Ma-ka-tai-me-she-kia-kiak, or Black Hawk. 1833. Available at Project Gutenberg: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/7097
- Prairie Farm Podcast interview with Dr. Patrick J. Jung, 2026
